Graphic Design work on a Budget

March 17, 2009 at 9:20 pm 1 comment

Building off our last article on building and maintaining your own website, I wanted to point you to a terrific article on finding a graphic designer on a budget.  Jason is spot on with his advice and I can personally attest to getting terrific results from

I’ll let Jason do the heavy lifting on picking a designer, but I’ll throw in a couple tips on utilizing sites like 99Designs and Crowdspring:

The Premise
The idea behind 99Designs, and other crowdsourcing sites, is that you submit a design project (e.g. make me a logo) to a large group of people, members of that group then submit designs to you,  and you get to pick (and pay for) the one you like best.  That means you get to look at, and refine, several designs for the price of one. 

Logistically speaking, you typically have a week from the start of your contest until you need to pick a winner.  As submissions come in, you get to rate and comment on them so that designers get to learn more about what you like and which direction you want to take the design.  At the end of the contest, you pick the winner, give them the money, they give you the original design elements and you’re off to the races for a couple hundred bucks and have saved yourself a couple hundred more in addition to some time and frustration interviewing designers.

The idea is simple but to get the most out of your experience, take a look at the following:

Do your Homework
While you won’t be designing the element, there’s still plenty of work to be done on your end to ensure you get the best design possible.  

  1.  Figure out what you want.  The more information you can provide about what you’re looking for in your description, the faster you’ll get designs you like and the more time you can spend refining them.
  2. Have examples ready.  Being able to point people to examples of things you like and things you don’t in your description will help a lot.  If pictures are worth 1k words to you and me,  they’re work 10k to designers.
  3. Find some designers on the crowdsourcing site and invite them to your contest.  Browse around other contests and as you do, take note of the designers you like.  Once you launch your contest, send them a note letting them know you really like their work and you’d like them to submit entries in your contest.  They’ll be happy to do so since they know you already like their style.
  4. Price it right.  Look at what other contest runners are giving away for similar work and be sure to price your contest competitively.  Remember, you’re competing for the good designers’ time, so make it worth their while.

It Must be Vector-Based
Be sure to specify that the final product of your contest must be “vector based.”  Don’t worry about the details of what that means, but know that if you don’t mention this and if someone gives you a pixel-based design, you’re up a stinky creek if you ever need to scale the work.  Unless you’re 100% positive you’ll never have to re-size whatever you’re getting designed…vector all the way.

Guarantee the Contest
The name of the game for a killer contest is to get as many good submissions, from as many good designers, as quickly as possible.  Doing so will give you ample time for refining your ideas (I’ve found it usually takes 3 or 4 iterations on a single idea before I consider it finished).

To make sure that happens, guarantee your contest.  That means you’ll be forced to hand over the cash for the contest, even if you’re not totally enamored with the winning design, but it’s worth it for a couple reasons:

  1. If you run the contest properly, there’s little chance you won’t be stoked about at least one design.  Remember, you’ll have the ability to tell designers exactly what you like and what you don’t about their submissions and they can fix them and resubmit them.  If you’re actively engauged in that process, there’s little chance every design will be a dud.
  2. If you run a contest and don’t pay out, forget about ever having another contest again.  Like on eBay, your reputation as a contest holder follows you, so designers will see that you flaked on your first contest and won’t waste their time a second time around.  Of course, you can create another account and start a-new, but you won’t get the reputation benefit of having run a successful contest.
  3. If you guarantee it, they will come.  Simply by ensuring you’re going to pay-out will bring more talented designers to your contest.
  4. Even if the winning design isn’t perfect, you can make minor tweaks afterwards.  Once you have the vector-based version of the design, you can have a friend, or even the winning designer,  make final tweaks to it.  After a week and a hundred+ submissions,  the couple hundred bucks you’ll pay will be well-worth the head start you’ll get on your final, perfect design.

Make the  Contest Private
Especially when you start out, and will get infinitely higher search rankings than your website so imagine what happens when someone searches for “your cool company name” on Google?  That’s right, your logo/website contest will show up as the first entry because the contest is full of phrases like,  “I want the logo for my cool company name to express…”.  That means your potential customers will see how you got your logo,  instead of reading about your services.

Making the contest private ensures search engines won’t cache your contest and your customers will focus on your tremendous offerings, not your tremendous design acquisition skills.

Provide Feedback 24/7
The #1, absolute, most important tip for running a crowdsource contest is that you need to provide high-quality, solution-centric, feedback all the time.  Feedback is your most important tool and you can use it to turn a “meh” design, into a “meh-arvelous” one.  (nice, huh?)

Keep in mind, most of the people submitting designs will not be in your timezone, or even close to it.  Financially speaking, it doesn’t make sense for designers in the US to participate in these contests much, so you’ll be working with designers on the other side of the planet.  If you don’t want to lose a day between iterations, be sure to comment on new submissions and give your designers feedback asap, even at midnight – it could be noon to them.

Also, feedback like, “Sorry, I don’t like it” is useless.  Be specific and if you can, provide suggestions on what you’d like to see – “Sorry, I’m not digging the mauve and vomit-green combo.  Perhaps mauve and puce?”  Also remember it’s not just one designer who will see your feedback – everyone who wants to enter your contest will see everyone else’s feedback.  So you’re not just talking to the guy who thought the devil horns were a nice touch, you’re also talking to the brilliant designer who is sitting back for a couple days and reading everyone else’s feedback before submitting her masterpiece.

Let me know how it goes
I’d love to see the results of your crowdsourced work, and hear about your experiences.  I’ve gotten some terrific designs from it and hope you get the same.

Best of luck!

Entry filed under: website. Tags: , .

Building & Maintaining your Website Searching on Twitter

1 Comment Add your own

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

What is this blog?

Our take on startups, healthcare, and what happens as we mix the two.

 RSS Feed

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 6 other followers

Our Company

Recent Posts


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: